What to Do if Your Health Insurance Claim Is Denied?

Published On: February 14, 2025

Last Updated: February 17, 2025

What to Do if Your Health Insurance Claim Is Denied?

You pay for health insurance to protect yourself from high medical costs, but what happens when your health insurance claim gets denied? It’s frustrating, confusing, and honestly, it can feel unfair. You might wonder, “Now what? Do I have to pay this entire bill myself?”

Take a deep breath, a denied claim does not mean you have no options. Many times, it happens because of paperwork mistakes, missing details, or something that can be fixed with an appeal. The good news is that many claims can be corrected or appealed, so you can still get the coverage you deserve. This guide will explain why requests for medical cost coverage get denied, what steps to take if your request is rejected, and how to prevent future denials. Let’s make sure you get the benefits you have been paying for.

Table of Contents

Why Do Health Insurance Claims Denied?

Your health insurance provider may deny a claim for several reasons. Understanding these reasons can help you fix the issue and avoid similar problems in the future.

1. Mistakes in the Paperwork

Believe it or not, even a small error can lead to a denied claim. If your name is misspelled, the policy number is incorrect, or important details are missing, your insurance company might not process it. It’s always a good idea to double-check the paperwork before submitting the claim.

2. Treatment Not Covered by Your Plan

Not every medical procedure, medication, or treatment is included in your health insurance policy. Some services might be excluded, and if the treatment you received isn’t part of your health insurance coverage, your claim could be denied. That’s why it’s always good to check what’s covered before getting treatment.

3. Visiting an Out-of-Network Doctor or Hospital

If you go to a doctor or hospital that is not part of your insurance network, your health insurance provider may either deny the claim or only cover part of the cost. To avoid surprises, always check if your provider is in-network before scheduling an appointment.

4. No Prior Authorization

Some treatments and medical procedures require preauthorization from your insurance company. This means you need approval before the treatment happens. If you skip this step, there’s a high chance your claim will be denied. If you’re unsure whether a procedure needs approval, call your health insurance provider to confirm.

5. Not Considered Medically Necessary

Even if a doctor recommends a treatment, your insurance company might decide it’s not medically necessary based on their guidelines. If this happens, they could deny the claim, leaving you responsible for the bill. In such cases, your doctor can provide additional medical proof to explain why the treatment was necessary.

6. Your Plan is No Longer Active

If your health insurance coverage has expired or you missed a payment, your insurance company may deny the claim. To avoid this, make sure your coverage is active and your payments are up to date before getting treatment.

Essential Steps to Take If Your Health Insurance Claim Is Denied

A denied health insurance doesn’t mean you should give up. You can take action to correct errors, provide additional information, or appeal the decision.

Steps to Take When Your Health Insurance Claim Is Denied

1. Read the Denial Letter Carefully

First, don’t ignore the denial letter. Your insurance company will send you a notice explaining why the request was denied. This letter will tell you:

  • The reason for the denial
  • The deadline to appeal the decision
  • The steps you need to take to challenge it

Knowing why your request was denied will help you decide what to do next.

2. Call Your Health Insurance Provider

Contact your insurance company’s customer service and ask them directly about the denial. Some important questions to ask include:

  • Was the request denied due to missing paperwork?
  • Does my doctor need to resubmit the request?
  • Are there other options to fix this issue?

Sometimes, a simple conversation can clear things up and get the request reconsidered without having to file an appeal.

3. Check Your Health Plan Benefits

Before moving forward, take a moment to review your health plan benefits. You’ll want to check:

  • Is this service covered under my plan?
  • Are there rules about in-network and out-of-network providers?
  • Did this procedure require prior authorization?

Knowing what your plan covers can help you argue your case when appealing the denial.

4. Fix Any Errors and Resubmit the Request

Sometimes, a denial is caused by simple mistakes. Work with your doctor’s office or healthcare provider to correct any errors and resubmit the request.

Common mistakes that can lead to denials include:

  • Incorrect personal details (name, date of birth, policy number)
  • Wrong billing codes
  • Missing medical records

Once everything is corrected, resubmit the request and follow up to ensure it is processed properly.

5. Get a Letter of Medical Necessity from Your Doctor

If the denial happened because the treatment was considered “not medically necessary,” don’t give up. Ask your doctor to write a Letter of Medical Necessity explaining:

  • Why the treatment was needed
  • Your medical history
  • Test results or reports that support the request

Providing strong medical evidence can increase your chances of getting the request approved.

6. File an Appeal

If your insurance provider still refuses to cover the service, you have the right to appeal. Insurance companies must review appeals fairly, so don’t hesitate to take this step.

How to File an Appeal

Step 1: Write an Appeal Letter

  • Explain why the denial is incorrect
  • Attach supporting documents such as medical records, doctor’s notes, and test results
  • Include a copy of the denial letter

Step 2: Submit Your Appeal Before the Deadline

  • Most insurance companies allow between 30 and 180 days to file an appeal
  • Submit the appeal through certified mail or your insurer’s online portal

Step 3: Follow Up Regularly

  • Contact your insurance provider to check the status of your appeal
  • Keep records of all communication

A strong appeal backed by medical proof and clear arguments can make a difference in getting the request approved.

7. Request an External Review

If your insurance company still denies the appeal, don’t lose hope. You can request an external review, where a third-party examiner will take another look at the case.

This independent review will determine if the insurance provider made the right decision. If the external review rules in your favor, your insurance company must approve the request.

How to Prevent Future Claim Denials?

At AHiX, we know that dealing with a denied request for coverage can be frustrating. The good news? There are steps you can take before getting medical care to reduce the chances of a denial. Here’s what you can do to keep things simple and stress-free.

1. Check Your Coverage Before Treatment

Before you schedule any medical procedure, test, or treatment, take a moment to call your health insurance provider. Ask if the service is covered under your health plan. This simple step can save you from unexpected surprises later.

2. Visit In-Network Doctors and Hospitals

Seeing doctors, specialists, and hospitals that are in your insurance network can help avoid claim issues and keep your out-of-pocket costs lower. If you’re unsure whether a provider is in-network, check your insurance company’s website or give them a call.

3. Get Prior Authorization When Needed

Some treatments or procedures need approval from your insurance provider before you receive them. This is called prior authorization. If it’s required and you don’t get it, your request could be denied. Always check before your appointment to avoid this problem.

4. Double-Check Your Paperwork

Believe it or not, small mistakes can lead to a denial. Before submitting any paperwork, make sure that:

  • Your name, policy number, and personal details are correct
  • Your doctor’s office is using the right billing codes
  • No important documents or signatures are missing

5. Keep Copies of Everything

It’s always a good idea to save copies of medical bills, doctor’s notes, test results, and insurance documents. If there’s ever a problem with your request for coverage, having these records can make the appeal process much easier. At AHiX, we believe that understanding your health coverage and taking these simple steps can help prevent denials before they happen. 

Understanding Your Health Insurance Coverage

Knowing what your health insurance coverage covers can help you avoid denied claims. Here are key terms you should understand:

1. Deductible

The amount you must pay out of pocket before your health insurance provider starts covering costs.

2. Copay

A fixed fee (before or after your deductible, depending on your plan) you pay for doctor visits or prescriptions, even after your health insurance plan begins covering costs.

3. Coinsurance

A percentage of the cost you must pay after meeting your deductible. For example, if your health insurance coverage covers 80%, you will pay 20%.

4. Out-of-Pocket Maximum

The most you have to pay for covered services in a year. After reaching this amount, your insurance company will cover 100% of the costs.

5. Explanation of Benefits (EOB)

A statement from your health insurance provider explaining what was covered and what you owe after a medical claim is processed.

What to Do if Your Appeal Is Denied?

If your health insurance claim appeal is denied, you still have options:

1. Request a Second Appeal

Just because your first appeal was denied doesn’t mean it’s the final decision. Many insurance companies allow you to submit a second appeal, especially if you can provide new evidence to support your claim.

Here’s what you can do:

  • Ask your doctor to write a Letter of Medical Necessity explaining why the treatment is important for your health.
  • Gather any new medical records or test results that support your case.
  • Make sure you understand the reason for the denial so you can address it directly in your second appeal.

2. Contact Your State’s Insurance Department

If you believe your health insurance provider is wrongfully denying coverage, you have the right to file a complaint with your state’s insurance department.

How can this help?

  • State regulators can review your case and ensure your insurance company is following the law.
  • They may step in to help resolve the dispute if they find that your claim was unfairly denied.
  • Some states even allow for an external review, where a neutral third party examines your case.

Each state has its own process, so check with your state insurance department for specific instructions.

3. Explore Alternative Payment Options

If your final appeal is denied, you still have ways to manage medical expenses without overwhelming costs. Here are some options to consider:

  • Ask Your Healthcare Provider About Payment Plans

Many hospitals and doctors’ offices offer payment plans that allow you to pay your medical bills over time instead of all at once.

  • Look for Financial Assistance Programs

Some healthcare providers have financial aid programs for patients who need help covering medical costs. Ask if you qualify for a discount or reduced-cost care.

  • Check for Discounts for Uninsured Patients

If your insurance company refuses to cover treatment, your healthcare provider may offer lower rates for patients paying out of pocket. Always ask if there’s a self-pay discount available.

Final Thoughts

A denied health insurance claim can be stressful, but you have options. By understanding the reasons for denials, taking the right steps to fix errors, and filing an appeal, you can increase your chances of getting your claim approved. At AHiX, we help you find the right health insurance plan to avoid common coverage issues. If you need expert guidance, visit AHiX.com today to explore your options.

FAQs

1. What is a health insurance claim?

A health insurance claim is a request for payment that you or your healthcare provider submit to your insurance company for medical services you’ve received. If the claim is approved, your insurance provider will pay part or all of the cost, depending on your health plan benefits.

Some healthcare providers submit claims on your behalf, while others may require you to file the claim yourself.

2. How do I fill out a health insurance claim form?

If you need to file a claim yourself, follow these steps:

  1. Get the Claim Form – You can download it from your insurance company’s website or request a copy.
  2. Provide Personal Information – Fill in your name, policy number, and contact details.
  3. Describe the Treatment – Include dates of service, medical provider details, and the reason for treatment.
  4. Attach Supporting Documents – Include medical bills, receipts, and doctor’s notes if required.
  5. Submit the Form – Send it via mail, fax, or online portal, as instructed by your insurance provider.
  6. Follow Up – Check with your health insurance provider to confirm they received your claim and ask about processing times.

At AHiX, we recommend double-checking the details before submitting to avoid delays or denials.

3. Can health insurance deny a claim after approval?

In most cases, once a claim is approved and paid, it cannot be reversed. However, there are rare situations where an insurance company may later determine that a claim was processed incorrectly and request a refund from the provider.

This usually happens due to:

  • Billing errors
  • Claims processed under the wrong policy
  • Fraudulent or incorrect claims

If this happens, you should contact your insurance provider and ask for a detailed explanation.

4. How often are health insurance claims denied?

While most health insurance claims are approved, denials happen more often than people expect. Studies show that 10-20% of claims may be denied due to:

  • Errors in paperwork
  • Lack of prior authorization
  • Out-of-network services
  • Treatments not considered medically necessary

At AHiX, we recommend always checking your health plan benefits and getting pre-authorization when required to avoid denials.

5. How do I get my health insurance to pay a claim?

If your insurance provider denied your claim, here’s what you can do:

  1. Review the Denial Letter – Understand why your claim was denied and check if it was due to a mistake.
  2. Contact Your Insurance Company – Ask them for more details and see if resubmitting the claim is an option.
  3. Fix Errors and Provide More Information – If a billing mistake or missing paperwork caused the denial, get it corrected and resubmit the claim.
  4. Request a Letter of Medical Necessity – If the treatment was deemed not necessary, ask your doctor to provide proof that it was required.
  5. File an Appeal – If you believe your claim was wrongly denied, you have the right to appeal the decision.

At AHiX, we help individuals find the right health coverage to reduce claim issues before they happen.

6. Why would health insurance deny a claim?

Your health insurance provider may deny a claim for several reasons, including:

  • Incorrect Information – A typo in your name, policy number, or medical codes can cause a denial.
  • Service Not Covered – Some treatments, medications, or procedures may not be included in your health insurance plan.
  • Out-of-Network Providers – If you visited a doctor or hospital outside your insurance network, your claim may be denied or partially covered.
  • No Prior Authorization – Some medical services require preapproval from your insurance company before treatment.
  • Medical Necessity Denial – If the insurance provider believes the treatment wasn’t essential, they may reject the claim.
  • Missed Premium Payments – If your health insurance coverage has expired due to a missed payment, your claim will be denied.

If your claim was denied, check the reason and follow the steps to appeal if needed.

7. What should I do if my claim for health insurance is denied?

If your claim is denied, don’t panic! Follow these steps to fix the issue and possibly get it approved:

  1. Read the denial letter carefully to understand the reason.
  2. Contact your health insurance provider and ask for clarification.
  3. Check your health coverage details to see if the service should have been covered.
  4. Correct any errors and resubmit the claim if needed.
  5. Ask your doctor for additional documentation to support the claim.
  6. File an appeal if you believe the claim was unfairly denied.

At AHiX, we encourage policyholders to stay informed about their coverage to prevent unnecessary denials.

8. Can I appeal a health insurance coverage claim denial?

Yes! If your claim is denied, you have the right to appeal the decision. Here’s how:

  • Step 1: Review the denial reason and gather any supporting documents.
  • Step 2: Write an appeal letter explaining why you believe the denial was wrong.
  • Step 3: Submit your appeal before the deadline (usually within 30 to 180 days).
  • Step 4: Follow up with your insurance company to check the status.

If your appeal is denied, you can request an external review by a third-party examiner.

Joe Barnes

Joe BarnesJoe Barnes, a nationally licensed insurance producer with years of experience, has assisted thousands in finding their ideal health insurance plan. Continuing his mission, Joe has embraced a writing editor role at AHiX. With his extensive knowledge of the insurance industry and deep understanding of our customer's needs, Joe guides our writing team, simplifying the process for readers to identify the best plan for their needs.

Ready To Shop?

Find A Plan That’s Right For You.

or

CALL 800.800.5735

Compare hundreds of budget plans in your region.